
Canada's Court: Oral Arguments from the SCC
Criminal Lawyers' Association 91 episodes Nov 17, 2026
Canada's Court is a podcast that presents selected oral arguments from the Supreme Court of Canada. It is produced by the Criminal Lawyers' Association and distributed on major podcast platforms. Each episode highlights a hearing, with full webcast video available from the Supreme Court of Canada website. The Supreme Court of Canada is not affiliated with the podcast and did not produce or participate in its creation.
Episodes

Episode 10: His Majesty the King, et al. v. B.F., et al.
B.F., a surgical nurse, had a child, E. In 2019, an interim family court ruling granted E.’s father supervised access, which B.F. resisted. At the time, B.F. was residing with her mother, I.F.On June 12, 2019, a neighbour found B.F., I.F., and E., then 19 months old, in B.F.’s home. All three were unconscious in B.F.’s bedroom. First responders found five empty insuli

Episode 9: His Majesty the King v. Sharon Fox
Sharon Fox is a criminal defence lawyer whose client was the subject of a wiretap authorization. This authorization did not permit live monitoring of phone calls with a lawyer. During the surveillance operation, a call between Ms. Fox and her client was automatically recorded. A civilian employee also listened to a portion of the call before disconnecting.A revie

Episode 8: His Majesty the King v. Kelly
Dayton Kelly was driving at night on Highway 86 in October 2021 when his car struck a horse-drawn buggy entering the highway from a sideroad. He was travelling well above the 80 km/hr limit. Both occupants of the buggy died. Blood samples later showed that the amount of THC in his blood was above the legal limit, and he was convicted of the basic offence of driving with an illegal a

Episode 7: His Majesty the King v. Bilinski
Jordan Bilinski was acquitted by a jury of sexual assault in Alberta. The complainant, his ex-girlfriend, had invited him over for sex on the express condition that he wear a condom. The evidence was that they had three sexual encounters that evening: oral sex without a condom, vaginal intercourse with a condom followed by ejaculation on her back, and then a final act of intercourse after she agai

Episode 6: His Majesty the King v. R.B.-C
R.B.-C. was convicted of sexual assault. He is an Iranian citizen living in Canada on a post-graduation work permit. But his sentence was not imposed until more than 14 months after his conviction. When it finally was imposed, he received a conditional sentence of two years less a day, followed by probation.Because of the delay in sentencing, R.B.-C. sought a stay of proceedings under section 11(b

Episode 5: His Majesty the King v. Harry Arthur Cope
Mr. Cope plead guilty to the aggravated assault of his common law partner. He had a significant criminal record, and a significant history of mental illness. Both he and his partner are Indigenous. The sentencing judge sentenced him to 5 years in custody for the aggravated assault, and eight months of custody for breaching the release orders he was subject to at the time of the aggravate

Episode 4: His Majesty the King v. Robert Joseph DeSutter
The respondent was charged with multiple counts of sexual offences in relation to three separate complainants, and in addition was charged with one count of simple assault. At trial, he was found guilty of the assault, but acquitted of the sexual offences. The trial judge found there was reasonable doubt on whether the acts were for a sexual purpose, and whe

Episode 3: His Majesty the King v. Robert Vrbanic, et al.
The two respondents, jointly tried for a number of drug trafficking and related charges, argued that the delay in their case was unreasonable. While both the Crown and Defence agreed at trial that the delay was over the 18-month presumptive Jordan ceiling, the Crown sought to justify the delay by arguing that the complexity of the case necessitated the delay. The trial judge di

Episode 2: W.W. v. His Majesty the King
Despite the fact that the trial judge found that the appellant sent sexually explicit material to a minor, the trial judge was left in doubt as to whether (a) the identity of the appellant was made out on the video as an element of the offence, and (b) the specific intent to commit one of the enumerated offences, reasoning that it could have been simply a case of “flirtation”. The appellant was ac

Episode 1: His Majesty the King v. Dylon Saddleback
Dylan Saddleback was convicted of second-degree murder in a judge alone trial. What was at issue on appeal was the trial judge’s use of statements made by the deceased during a phone call to a 3rd party, who testified at trial. The duration of that same phone call was important because the trial judge found that this is when the killing took place, as the 3rd par

Episode 7: S.A. v. His Majesty the King
S.A.’s trial for the charges of assault and sexual assault, was scheduled to commence on April 17, 2023. He elected to be tried by judge and jury. On the trial date, a judge was unavailable to preside, so the trial did not commence. A subsequent trial date was scheduled for February 12, 2024. The defence brought an 11(b) application. The 11(b) application judge s

Episode 6: J.W. v. His Majesty the King
The appellant, an Indigenous man with significant cognitive difficulties, repeatedly sexually assaulted a worker at the group home where he resided. He remained in custody pending trial, including a period of detention in a psychiatric facility while temporarily unfit to stand trial. After resiling from three agreements to plead guilty, the appellant did so the fourth time. From charge to convicti











